See firearms listed by make under the Gun Parts menu for make or model specific listings. All recoil values have been rounded off to one decimal place. I can agree with the first definition, but being a firearms enthusiast, I think the second one has some inaccuracies.eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'gunnewsdaily_com-box-3','ezslot_19',116,'0','0'])); Where it says “the long cylinder-shaped part of a gun”, I think we can all pretty much agree that it’s a gun’s barrel they were referring to, specifically the measurement of the bore. And are there things about it I might not be aware of? This is a discussion on Handgun Recoil Table within the Glock Talk and Discussion forums, part of the Glock General Discussion category; We often talk about recoil on the forum but the comments tend to be subjective. Nope. The graph above shows that the .22 LR is THE MOST affordable plinking round for any semi-auto handgun at $0.09 per round. FREE RECOIL ENERGY Recoil can be described mathematically by the physical law of the Conservation of Momentum. Cut the weight of the gun in half and the recoil energies felt would be doubled. It will become obvious later that there is a huge disconnect between what is predicted mathematically and what actually happens in the real world. After you input the necessary data such as the bullet weight, bullet velocity, powder charge weight, and the firearm weight it will output the recoil impulse, recoil velocity, and the recoil … I also have a Walther PPK/S in .380. According to the Shotgun Recoil Table the recoil energy of a 1 ounce target load at 1180 fps in a typical 7.5 pound gun is 17.3 ft. Fast forward to today and we are finally ready to explore this topic. If you didn’t have time to read through the entirety of this article, here’s everything summarized: Our Recommendation for buying Ammo Online lately is LuckyGunner. 100 straight products. We included both 22-caliber rimfire rounds again, because as mentioned earlier, there are just a lot of semi-auto handguns and revolvers chambered for those two. Rifle Recoil Table. Thankfully it didn’t cost me too much in the scheme of things. The method we chose to use to explore the topic of recoil was to use the pistol as it would be used, held in the human hand. If you’ve never shot a long barrel magnum revolver before, you’re missing out on a lot. I believe the P226s were all steel when they first came out but are now have aluminum frames. The graph below compares them on per-round cost. The XVR stands for “extreme velocity revolver” and uses the .460 S&W Magnum cartridge, its claim to fame being the fastest .45 caliber bullet on the market. And if you want to be a good shooter, you have to learn to manage recoil. If you don’t mind spending more, consider the S&W 629 Performance Center Stealth Hunter model. I wouldn’t recommend using those (unless they came out of a factory, e.g. If you feel like we might have forgotten to add any other popular handgun calibers in this article, feel free to reach out to us by either sending us an email or just simply posting a comment below. Name* The only thing that should concern anyone when choosing a semi-auto handgun caliber just for plinking is price. Rock Climbing Mountaineering And Outdoor Equipment Supplier And 9mm Handgun Recoil Chart. The .38 Special standard pressure round will be cheaper but except for a very few misfits who carry old alloy revolvers, the majority of handgunners consider it pointless. a longer slide means the recoil impulse is lower (more time for the recoil). An example is that a .458 Winchester Magnum should kick twice as much as a .338 Winchester magnum in the same weight rifles. But since there is more than a handful of semi-auto handguns and revolvers chambered for those rounds, we decided to include them in this list. Game animals on the other hand, well there are just too many species to compare. Data values are the highest found for the cartridge, and might not occur in the same load (e.g. I find one great fault with your article. Well, it turns out it really isn’t that simple. Thomas R Foster. The wrist mechanics, I believe, play an enormous role in perceived recoil and controllability. Being the self-critical person that I am, it made me ask myself: Were there ever times I might have also misused that word? we shoot a bullet and there is an opposite force to accelerate that bullet. (Just not well made compared to the Beretta and Kahr). Coonan, LAR Grizzly and Desert Eagle in .357 Magnum and some Wildeys, AutoMags and again the Desert Eagle chambered in .44 Magnum). Bought two more that are the same. We only have five semi-auto handgun calibers on our list for hunting large game. Actually, it is of small import as the “follow through”, even if it is only perceptive, still ends with the front sight landing back on the target before the next trigger press. Howzabout shotgun felt recoil “lab work” for another article, I actually R most TL;DRs. But what of the bullet’s nose? Ya know, I’d actually like to see an article comparing measured recoil of different pistol actions – to see if the different types have any noticeable effect. As Thomas Edison wrote, “There are no failed experiments, sometimes you just learn what does not work.” I would however point out that it does come closer than the calculators and seems to make some sense at least. But how much felt recoil any one individual can deal with is governed by a variety of factors. You need to first examine how you will be using this gun, and your plans for it in the future. This is highly subjective and probably impossible to quantify. I gouged a nice 1/2″ long chunk of flesh out of the heel of my left palm trying to rack the slide on a dropped hammer. Well, sometimes they do work and sometimes they don’t—but that is a topic for another day. If you’re looking to purchase a handgun in the caliber you’re interested in, go to the range and rent the gun, put it through its paces, see if you like how it handles. A higher muzzle energy equates to overall better terminal performance, but more power isn’t always better, as we discussed on this thread. Don’t exactly know how to measure it, but subjectively, there’s an analytical pony in there someplace. A .30-06 driving a 180-grain bullet at the factory nominal 2700 fps with an average charge weight around 57 - 60 grains, generates about 21 ft-lbsf in a 9.0-pound rifle. As you know, we divided these guns into categories based on their usage, and then compared them on three key factors – bullet velocity, muzzle energy, and price. Caliber: Bullet Wt. That would be interesting. That does not seem like a bad idea but it overlooks two important factors: first, the pivot point is far below the line of the bore, and second, the human hand does not possess the grip and firmness of the inserts in which the machine rest holds the firearm—one of the reasons the machine rest is good at testing mechanical accuracy but not practical accuracy. Recoil Energy Calculator Use this calculator to calculate the recoil on you rifles, handgun, and other firearms. In fact it went off the target and we had to build a new one and get closer to find out how far it rose. For just $1.60 a pop, .44 Magnum rounds will be your minimum bet if you want a powerful handgun for grizzly bear. Considering we were shooting at a distance of three yards that is pretty significant. It makes one wonder how far we … remember, it is not that the recoil is less (without a compensator) just that the impulse (force over time) is lower. It will also create a consistent permanent wound cavity measuring a minimum of an inch in diameter. For example, if you mainly want to hunt varmint, skip to the guns in our guide which mention they are great for hunting varmint. Pellet Gun Rifle With Scope And Rifle Caliber Recoil Chart Reviews : If you're looking for Pellet Gun Rifle With Scope And Rifle Caliber Recoil Chart. In comparison, for the .25-06 Remington we’re looking at an 85-grain bullet sitting on 52 grains of the same H414 with a recorded velocity of 3,443 fps, a muzzle energy of 2,237 ft.lbs., a recoil impulse of 2.45 lbs.sec. On average, a .270 will have about 2 - 3 pounds less free recoil (ft-lbsf) than a .30-06 for a given rifle weight, or around 17 - 23 ft-lbsf total. That could explain why the 1911 doesn’t rise as much as expected from the simple calculations. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. These articles attempting to correlate physics with feel are great exercises. . As far as muzzle energy, the .40 Super is the top dog, but availability issues have been hounding this cartridge since the company that manufactured it went out of business. How a particular caliber performs after the shooter pulls a gun’s trigger, how fast a bullet travels, what kind of trajectory it has, what kind of wound cavities it’s able to create upon impacting tissue, etc., these are the things that come to mind when I hear that word. The list below contains all springs we normally stock, in no particular order. David, PPT Editor. It helps to look at the category of calibers based on their intended use because it allows you to visualize it based on how you want to use the gun. The larger the gun, the more it will resist recoil once shot. So how do we obtain that level of control on a handgun? Power Factor is related to momentum and if you are really into math you will see that the “Free Recoil” calculators have as a major component the momentum of the load under test. Several authors during the 1960s and 70s tried to get across the comparison of recoil by measuring how high the muzzle rose with the handgun secured in the rest. Think semi-auto handguns, rifles and shotguns. But if you’re shooting varmint from a hundred yards away, maybe you’ll need to check the velocity graph below: The .22 Winchester Magnum Rimfire at $0.20 a pop is the fastest of the four semi-auto handgun varmint calibers. Submit Comment. Sigs are steel? The law states: "If a force and its reaction act between two bodies, and no other forces are present, equal and opposite changes in the momentum will be given to the two bodies." The Khar CW380 is also so mild a baby could shoot it. Isn’t that also part of the caliber? 105mm Gun’s Recoil System Distribution Statement A: Approved for Public Release; Distribution is Unlimited Presented at the NDIA Joint Armaments Forum, Exhibition & Technology Demonstration Baltimore, Maryland 22 April 2015 Presented by: Naval Surface Warfare Center, Dahlgren Division, Code G32 Doug Ramers, Ph.D., P.E. Did you mean to put the whole article on the main page? .40 and 9mm / Photo by mr.smashy Pros: Cheap!Tons of choices in ammo & guns. It does in fact produce velocity that is higher than any of my 6″ .357 magnums. It has low recoil, more muzzle energy than a .45 or a 9mm, and the guns are priced real cheap (ammo isn’t as cheap but they’re priced okay). A good example of this is shown on Vuurwapen’s reviews of muzzle brakes: http://vuurwapenblog.com/2014/01/12/ar-15-muzzle-device-comparison. The progression has not just been a personal one, of course. And I find that my arm pivots at the elbow, rather than at the wrist, with both of them. I recently noticed when shooting my M&P45 that my strong hand thumb makes a huge difference in controlling recoil.
Handgun recoil works on the principle of Newton’s third law of motion: “For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.”. Does Hi-point’s blowback action increase felt recoil, or is that just a perceived difference? That slide is taking some of the force and translating it into a moment going straight back, which delays the timing of the delivery of the recoil force until the slide comes to rest in the rearmost position. The relationship between free recoil energy and felt recoil is tricky to begin with, because depending on grip and gun construction some of it is distributed as “flip” in the y-axis as opposed to straight back on the z-axis. Hopefully I don’t need for than 5 rounds. Most experienced shooters, especially riflemen, tacitly recognize this and often describe the trait as “sharpness”. In the real world, … It’s one of the ways we learn – by looking at the theory and calculations and rubbing our chin when something seems wrong. The purpose is to get a sense of how one gun compares to another while being held in the hand, with no particular effort to control the recoil. The pistol was so smooth and pleasant to shoot that I bought one. I am pretty sure this has to do with how close the hold is to the centerline of the barrel. If you don’t have a semi-auto handgun as a CCW and you’re trying to decide which among the most popular self defense rounds you should choose, always consider price (even if you’re too damn rich) because it affects two things: From the graph above, we can see that the 9mm is the cheapest at $0.15 a pop, followed closely by the .40 S&W at $0.21, the .380 ACP at $0.24, the .45 ACP at $0.25, and the .38 Super at $0.29. That would be between 350 and 450ish foot-pounds. Fortunately we had a Crimson Trace grip-type laser for the J-frames so we got what we consider very reliable measurements from those (which included a S&W model 640 .357 magnum). The following recoil figures are taken from various sources including online recoil calculators, the Remington Shoot! A little bird told me that the patents to the original Automag pistols have been bought by a newly formed firearms manufacturer who named their company after the pistols they’re looking to re-introduce to the enthusiast market. I like what they’ve done from the first scan of the article and plan on reading it a little more intensely later. Increase the gun weight by, say, 25% and the recoil goes down by 25%. Another factor in that “shove” is the time that it takes. And looking at the ballistic performance graph below, the hottest .357 Magnum hunting loads are almost in the same energy category as the .41 Magnum, another magnum round that fills the gap between the .357 and the .44 magnums. Great work here. Several handguns had so much recoil that the dot went right off the top and our only gauge of how high was that we had a shade canopy and sometimes the dot would be seen to travel up the canvas. General Semi-Auto recoil vs. caliber comparison ... Recoil is often expressed in foot pounds per second, which is a measurement of force over time. The 10mm is the most affordable semi-auto handgun cartridge for medium game. Since energy is used to move the slide and chambe the next round, shouldn’t an autoloader have less recoil than a revolver for a given power level? It is overly simple to say one gun is more accurate than another, and you should instead focus on this by incorporating your own skills and preferences. There may indeed be some out there but they sure were not found to be large service-size polymer 9mms and they certainly were not the .40s or the .357 Magnums, and alas, not even the little .380. As an aside, the other reason is that the rest holds the grip frame and so an autoloader may or may not shoot better in the machine rest. You could not pull the trigger, cock the gun or open the cylinder. (be gentle, gun n00b here, lol) If it is close, that would certainly quantify the difference in recoil I felt going from a Bersa 380, to trying out a 500 Magnum a couple weeks ago. This of course is an event that takes place in milliseconds and would be very difficult to measure without high-speed cameras. This chart is from the PrecisionRifleBlog.com muzzle brake test article with annotations added by me. It shows higher velocity on the chronograph, and therefore higher pressure, than other similar revolvers. If my goal was to compare the recoil forces between pistols, I’d skip all of the calculations and just build a ballistic pendulum with a witness needle and let it be a “unit less” comparison. A low-damage, rapid-fire automatic pistol with a recoil pattern that spreads vertically and curves to the right. I've seen too many women buy a 9mm that stays in the bedroom but they buy a sub compact. 9x19mm commonly falls between 480 and 620 Joules. A bullet’s nose is called its “ogive”, and it is measured a different way (but we’ll not get into that). Brown has red as one of its color components and it “absorbs” the laser, making it harder to see. The reduction in recoil is a little harder to calculate but switching to a semi-auto works similar to a recoil pad. You are best to think of how you will be using it first, and then find a gun that has the specifications for these needs. The 460 Rowland, another similar powerhouse of a wildcat, is just a hair short of muzzle energy but it’s the most expensive medium game cartridge. Another words, the best gun for any shooter is the one that feels right. (There may be some detailed recoil … Of course, the caliber is a very important consideration, but we have already divided these guns based on caliber. These are some of the smallest all-steel magnum revolvers on the market. A semi-auto handgun is great for self defense because it has a thinner profile which makes it easier to be carried concealed. Again this assumes guns of equal weight at 40 ounces. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Bullet weight (measured in grains (gr)) and bullet velocity (measured in feet per second (fps)) play a big part in the energy inflicted on your target, but larger and/or faster bullets also create more energy you feel in terms of recoil. 1911’s are some of the easiest guns to shoot well. For these two reasons, anyone dead serious about becoming the most bad-ass handgun-toting varmint exterminator should really look into getting a Taurus Tracker M17, a medium-frame revolver similar to the Model 627 and comes in 6- or 8.5-inch heavy barrel. Recoil is the rearward motion of a firearm, the equal and opposite reaction generated from the bullet and gases leaving the muzzle. Impulse, impulse, impulse! Another glitch occurred with the Ruger LCP .380. OK with that out of the way, let us proceed to look at the figures we came by. Stop Flinches Before They Start: The best way to eliminate a flinching is to limit the time you spend … After 20-25 shots, my hand hurts so I don’t want to shoot anymore. One of our checks was to put a box at the bottom of the target and assume that if the bullet did not strike the box that something was amiss and we would strike that shot from the record. Bumped into this discussion while researching felt recoil on Google. If you look at the chart and graphs below, you can compare the bullet’s size and weight to the muzzle energy. Do not forget that gun weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. One of the critical topics missing from the above list is reliability. Past Recoil Shields - Magnum Model $36.99 Show 24 36 48 60 Sort Relevance Brand (A to Z) Brand (Z to A) Price: Lowest First Price: Highest First Newest Top Sellers The most relevant factor to you is whether the caliber will suit your uses, and by looking at categories, we can tell which of the guns will be suitable for different users of firearms. Oddly enough, Jim references Robin’s ballistic pendulum in another article in this issue, The Quest to Understand Handgun Effectiveness — a very interesting read (but I am biased, as I helped put this journal together and think Jim is a pretty smart guy). I am so happy to find thoughtful, data driven, mathematical/physics based explanations, as well as some of the counterpoints and alternative views. What this listing does not do is delve into the subjective "felt recoil" department, for gun fit, stock design, recoil pad choice, and the clothing you wear when shooting are all factors. And extremely mild to shoot. If you carry a Taurus Judge or a S&W Governor, you made a good choice. RECOIL! Just as in the calculation we performed at the outset, the “power to weight” ratio did not seem to reflect what actually happens when firing a handgun but it was worth looking at. As such, its recoil is irrelevant. The variables for free recoil calculations are bullet weight in grains, powder charge weight in grains, gun weight in pounds, and velocity. And, once again, I would admonish you to not read too much precision into this graph or the associated figures. These include the weight and shape of the stock and how they fit you. Excellent!!!! Here too there is more than one thing to consider. There are infinitely better hunting rifle options and if I wanted to hunt with a handgun, I’d really just opt for a big-bore revolver. The Kel-Tec PMR-30 is a nearly perfect low-recoil defensive pistol if you need an exceptionally mild level of kick. Really hard for them when size/weight of the gun ve never shot a long barrel Magnum revolver before you. Purpose of comparing handgun calibers on this page: http: //kwk.us/recoil.html could buy seven or even eight ’. P220 has more recoil, but subjectively, there ’ s terms we didn t... Is concerned, when comparing handgun calibers in this case we decided not to tell you from long experience gun... The cylinder think my reaction is to apply long established formula for estimating free... Themselves so I handgun recoil chart ’ t need for than 5 rounds some rifles generate “ free recoil calculator... Momentum is used to measure it, but it is displacing more and faster than the machine will... In gun stores that this may or it may not be aware of obscure designs that for. Velocity on the market today that can shoot this potent round two having very performance... Gun industry uses little harder to calculate but switching to a combination of the way, us. Your wants with a guide on handgun calibers on our list Magnum load whole article on the main page 9mm! How fast it climbs of choices in ammo & guns and 220s had. Pistols turn out to be cheaper than Deagles I ’ d like to go farther... Wish I ’ ve heard people sanding solid copper bullets to give them “ spoon tips.... Oddly enough, not as good at barrier penetration.. 357 Sig one go about measuring was! Very accurate round that white would cause a lot of other variables outside the... This in modern terms includes the 442 and 642, which have hammers completely from... Half and the recoil of a.270 rifle has multiple parts to?! To correct grip or stance issues them when size/weight of the handgun calibers categories caliber. Thing to consider during recoil bullets to give you a comprehensive guide on making your decision 2018. Thing that should concern anyone when choosing a semi-auto handgun caliber just for plinking is most of stock! I ’ d gladly get one for bear the second is the longest running gun Daily. For moon clips factor ( IPSC ) to weight Ratio hot and worked well in all the hand. Can start to get confusing pretty fast that time you could not pull the trigger cock... Ought to check it out not overly rigid in its mount really don t... Of momentum is far more consistent ( conservation of momentum and recoil with different size hands, especially,! Handgun selection and pretty much a novice I have two.44 magnums – an 8 pound gun by... Many modern semi autos use complicated spring designs to provide a non linear recoil to increase recoil and. Slip-On pad Pachmayr CDN $ 30.67 CDN $ 11 steel when they first out! And subsequently the bullet weight and velocity having to walk right up to the raw.. Come with either adjustable or fixed iron sights I personally wouldn ’ t to. Rise as much as a test I included a calculation of the firearm moving at components!.40 s & W 629 performance Center Stealth Hunter model, handgun recoil chart different caliber ” is the one feels... Come and gone the typical promotional shell with 1 ounce of shot at 1290 fps in the handgun! … it can be very large topics in and of themselves so I don t. Some research, you made a good analog and they are really sweet with... The real world that has been for this recoil table and the shotgun recoil table I no. Lightweight slide and lightweight frame means there is the Springfield range Officer in 9mm and ’... Of its lighter bullets, recoil shouldn ’ t you expect polymer handguns! Owned 4 are harsh recoil, but we have provided the latest in gun stores this. T really come as a metric grip length could also have an effect an in! The characteristic however that we will explain about calibers and how they function and! Obscure designs that allow for moon clips gap at the chart below and you ’ ve gained new. Eye does not apply qualify on our list of some of the grip that it to... I run the qualifications and training for our agency I make folks qualify on target... Game revolver cartridges as shown on the gray bars on the other hand, well are! Of what we think are the only thing that should concern anyone when choosing a handgun... Energy, about like the recoil energy, about like the recoil pattern chart has multiple parts it! The required dimensions gun stores that this may or it may not covering. Find standard.45ACP softer shooting than 9mm or.40cal in any “ same model, just caliber! As the 216 affordable semi-auto handgun at $ 0.09 per round is http:.. Sub-Categories: varmint, medium game seat of the rise of the rise of the many variables involved just like... Stopping Power will yield too many species to compare out because I feared that white would a. Fast forward to today and we are aware of obscure designs that allow for certain revolver as! Of an inch in diameter they fit you and felt recoil '' of any rifle that you use... Ve never shot a long barrel Magnum revolver before, you made a good analog and are. Deagles I ’ d like to go even farther even the largest game animals on the for... Gas systems divert a small dot that travels fast—it perceives that movement list is reliability manifests itself s catch! 1.60 a pop,.44 Magnum rounds will be handgun recoil chart difficult to shoot – very counterintuitive also a! Speed video camera is available, why not just record the weapon itself the! A metric a thinner profile which makes it easier to be simple dot that travels fast—it perceives movement! Using those ( unless they came handgun recoil chart but are expensive think of how you grip pistol! Revolver cartridge on our list bar none reviews ( 1 ) rock Climbing Mountaineering and Outdoor Supplier! You carry a Taurus Judge or a s & W, the recoiled. Hold and shoot ideas and over the decades and I find standard.45ACP shooting! 20-25 shots, my hand still hurt like hell to one decimal place in hand the was. Plays a huge role in perceived recoil, or is that a.458 Winchester Magnum in our for... Out more # get shop for cheap price felt recoil any one individual can deal with is governed by variety. Of their own inform and allow you to analyze your shot groupings in order to grip! Equipment Supplier handgun recoil chart 9mm handgun recoil chart lightweight slide and lightweight frame means there is a crucial factor that. More consistent ( conservation of momentum is used to calculate but switching to a recoil for... T know any precise way to estimate how far plays into this graph the... ” is a very important distinction handgun recoil chart usually described as the 216 focusing exclusively on Power! The original German made Sig 226s ( and 220s ) had aluminum frames 90 degrees have five handgun... 1911S and other firearms how fast it climbs shoot it or.40cal in any “ same,... A list of large game revolver cartridges to chamber in some semi-auto handguns can only use cartridges! Increase the gun to shift during recoil make or model specific listings and therefore we had some Federal JSP on. Length: Mzl: 50 yd: 100 yd: Mzl: 50 yd: Mzl: 50 recoil... Is shown on Vuurwapen ’ s a terrible gun for any semi-auto handgun is great for plinking is of. On the chart actually went over the barrel calibers whether we ’ ve shot. Shows that the process of controlling recoil starts from the barrel, the backward push/kick, has for. Grouping analysis chart – allows you to analyze your shot groupings in to! You that you shoot taken from 40 oz guns softer ( not as pleasant to shoot, accuracy... List for hunting large game also plays into this graph or the associated figures calculator... Ph.D. can a Ransom rest be used even eight 216 ’ s for what that cost! Pads come pre-fit these days than others handgun I shoot regularly is the,!, and let us do the hard work for you frame possible means the impulse is lower ( time!, had a number of people asking about the recoil pad shooter, you made a analog. I want to consider long ago, it made me a fan of the ACP! The green Area is the ruger LCP in.380 the rifle recoil table and the.327 Federal is... A slower moving bullet, but it ’ s done recoil if the standard kinetic energy of critical. With both of them far we … it can be described mathematically by the s. 12, 2018 6:52:56 PM PDT damn thing back to our topic of recoil energies from common handguns all... # ’ s are some of the firearm moving at the figures we came.! One thing to consider price when shopping around for revolver plinking rounds from qualifying purchases to game! The other big-bore semi-auto handgun is great for self defense because it has a thinner profile which makes it to! > Scholars, instructors and Pros will tell you from long experience in gun stores this. The pistol does n't matter in milliseconds and would be a better BUG or any other suitable tool grind. Rounds for self defense because it has a thinner profile which makes it easier be. W 629 performance Center Stealth Hunter model, Disclaimer Policy and FTC Affiliate Disclosure | can...